
Lisa See is an amazing writer. I felt as if I were living the story. Two sisters live in Shanghai in 1937 - just at the time the Japanese begin to invade Shanghai. This is their story, written from the point of view of the older sister, and how they came to America. They settled in China Town in Los Angeles, married to two brothers. It is the story of their life - a very hard life - until 1957.
I thought the writing was great, but my lasting impression was "what a depressing book." While I was reading there were enough hopeful moments in the book that I kept reading, sure that things would almost always work out for the best. They never did. It was fascinating to read of their lives, which were indicative of life in China Town at that time, because I always love to learn about those things, but when I finished the book I just had a heavy feeling.
Bottom line, I can't fully endorse the book without the warning that it is a depressing story. And I didn't feel the ending salvaged that at all. In fact, it reinforced it.
I read Snow Flower and the Secret Fan by Lisa See a couple of years ago, and thought it was excellent. Life was hard in that book also, but somehow I don't remember it feeling dark. I must have read it before I started my blog, because I looked for a review on it, and there isn't one. I wholly recommend Snow Flower and the Secret Fan.










